Category: Opinion

Write For Us

Interesting in writing for TheNewsCaravan ?
From opinion pieces to features, from interviews with legends to stories for the kids, TheNewsCaravan offers space to all right kind of ideas that have the potential of stirring imagination and bringing chance.

To explore more, drop in an email to the editor at thenewscaravan@gmail.com or info@thenewscaravan.com

  • Justice Katju : Husaini Brahmins

    Justice Katju : Husaini Brahmins


    Moharram, an important occasion for Muslims, is going on these days,
    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Muharram
    I may tell an interesting story in this connection related by Intizar Husain, an eminent Pakistani novelist, short story writer, and poet.
    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Intizar_Hussain
    This is in his own words :
    WITH the arrival of Muharram this year, I was reminded of an encounter I had with an unusual, intelligent girl in Delhi. I recalled referring to Prem Chand’s play ‘Karbala‘ in one of my addresses, which was based on a legend. The legend was about a group of eight Hindu brothers who had somehow reached Karbala determined to die fighting for the cause that Imam Husain stood for. They fought bravely and sacrificed their lives in devotion to Imam Husain.


    It was in this context that I was talking about Husaini Brahmans, who seemed to have vanished from
    the social scene in India.

    All of a sudden, a girl from among the audience stood up and challenged my statement. She said, ‘Here I am before you. My name is Nonica Dutt. I belong to a Husaini Brahman family.’ It was clearly a pleasant surprise for me,
    something like discovering a rare bird while walking through a jungle.

    The girl promised me an exclusive meeting to enlighten me with interesting information about the Husaini Brahman background of her family. But the proposed meeting kept on being postponed for one reason or the other.
    Finally, on the last day of my stay in Delhi, I received a call from her.

    ‘Let us meet now,’ she said

    ‘But I have no evening to spare for you. Today is the last day of my stay in your city,’ I said.

    ‘But I am already in the lounge and I must meet you,’ she said.

    So we finally had a meeting. She entered my room with two large volumes under her arm. I proposed a detailed sitting on my next visit, which was due after a month or so.
    ‘But in the coming months, I will not be in Delhi. I am
    moving to Germany and will spend four months at the Humboldt University.’
    Nonica Dutt taught history at Jawahar Lal University, Delhi and had been honoured with a fellowship from the Humboldt University. Hence she was on her way to Germany.

    She said, ‘ I told my mother about your comments regarding Husaini Brahmans and how I introduced myself as one. To that she said, did you tell him that we don’t perform the rituals the Brahmans are obliged to perform. That we don’t go to the temples?’

    ‘Should I presume from this,’ I asked, ‘that you have turned Muslim.’

    ‘No, we are not Muslims,’ she exclaimed.

    ‘Then what are you?’ I inquired.

    ‘We are Husaini Brahmans,’ she said with a certain sense of pride and added,
    ‘Now, I will tell you about a sign each and every Husaini Brahman carries with him/her. On his/her throat s/he bears a line of cutting, which is indicative of the fact that s/he is the descendant of those Brahmans whose throats were cut in the battle of Karbala.’
    Then she told me about the ritual carried out on the birth of every child in her family. She said,
    ‘Among Brahmans, after child birth, the ritual of Moondan is performed. In our family this ritual is performed in the name of Imam Husain.’

    She then went on to tell me the historical facts.
    ‘I will now tell you about the history of our martyred forefathers.’ Pointing to the two books placed on the table she said, ‘Our entire history is conserved within these two
    books. When needed, I will quote from them.’ Considering their worn out and pale pages, the books, which were written in English, seemed to be centuries old.

    The history of Husaini Brahmans, as told by Nonica Dutt, begins with ten Brahmans going to Karbala with the determination to die fighting for Imam Husain. Among them were Rahib Dutt and his seven sons who fought bravely and
    resolutely.
    They met their death in a heroic way. Rahib Dutt was the lone survivor of the battle. From Karbala he escaped to Kufa, where he stayed for some time. It is said that Rahib had
    the privilege of meeting the members of the Imam’s family after the massacre. He introduced himself by saying, ‘I am a Brahman from Hindustan.’
    The reply came, ‘Now you are Husaini Brahman. We will always remember you.’

    Rahib went from Kufa to Afghanistan, and from there came back to India where he stayed for a few days in Nankana. Nonica paused for a while and then spoke, ‘In the Sialkot district there is a town known as Viran Vatan. That place is our ancestral home. We are the descendants of Rahib Dutt.
    She then recited a few couplets from the book she had
    brought along with her, in which these incidents have been recorded. ‘These couplets,’ she said, ‘are very popular among the Husaini Brahmans.’

    Nonica shut the book and said ‘Let me inform you that Sunil Dutt, the famous film actor, was also a Husaini Brahman. And the father of his wife Nargis too was a Husaini Brahman.’

    She got up saying ‘Now I must go.’

    ‘I think,’ I said, ‘after you return from Germany, I should make a point to come to Delhi so that you can introduce me to your father. I will perhaps be able to know much more about your ancestors from him.’

    She said goodbye and left hurriedly. I had been under the impression that the story of the eight Brahmins was just a legend. But Nonica said it is a historical fact. And it is the belief of Nonica and her community that really counts. For them the event is a reality.

    https://thewire.in/religion/the-forgotten-history-of-hussaini-brahmins-and-muharram-in-amritsar

  • Justice Katju: Kalidas Ghalib Foundation ( KGF ) meeting 2023

    Justice Katju: Kalidas Ghalib Foundation ( KGF ) meeting 2023


    Yesterday, 20th July, we held an important lunch meeting of Kalidas Ghalib Foundation KGF ( of which I am the patron ) in Karim’s restaurant in the India Islamic Cultural Centre, Delhi. It was attended inter alia by the Chairman of Kalidas Ghalib Foundation (KGF ) Naushad Ali Syed ( naushadalisyed@gmail.com ), Ershad Alam, the National Gen Secy ( ershad.aalam@gmail.com ), Bharat Thakur ( btyoga@gmail.com ), Ajay Upadhyaya, Sonam, and others.


    The object of Kalidas Ghalib Foundation is to promote the composite culture of India ( Ganga Jamuna tehzeeb ), which is very important today when powerful forces are trying to polarise society and spread communal, caste and ethnic hatred in the country.


    https://thenewscaravan.com/kalidas-ghalib-academy-by-justice-katju/


    Kalidas Ghalib Foundation had been very active at one time. We held functions in Kolkata, Mumbai, Delhi etc on various cultural and literary subjects, which were largely attended.. However, thereafter it became inactive, so we have now decided to reactivate it.


    https://thenewscaravan.com/the-need-for-reviving-and-revamping-kalidas-ghalib-foundation-by-justice-katju/


    We have also decided to set up state units in India and even units abroad e.g. in USA, UK, etc
    We will hold functions of KGF in many cities in India, as well as online global webinars, on various cultural and literary topics.

    The first function will be held in Kolkata in which I will speak on the role of art and literature in contemporary India.


    All those interested in joining us may contact me ( justicekatju@gmail.com ) or the others whose email ids are given above. They may also give us ideas how to proceed

  • Bengalis are emotional not rational, on some issues

    Bengalis are emotional not rational, on some issues


    Justice Katju


    Are Tagore and ‘Netaji’ holy cows and private property of Bengalis ? Is no one permitted to raise any questions about ‘Gurudeb’ and ‘Netaji’ ?


    https://www.hastakshepnews.com/are-tagore-and-bose-the-private-property-of-bengalis/


    I regard Tagore as objectively a British agent, and Subhas Chandra Bose as a Japanese agent.


    https://www.andhrawishesh.com/378-telugu-headlines-top-stories/52102-bose-a-japanese-agent-and-tagore-a-british-stooge-katju.html


    One evening at Allahabad when I was a Judge there ( 1991-2004 ) I was at the house of one of the High Court Judges who had invited some judges for dinner.
    There I mentioned my view that Subhas Chandra Bose was a Japanese agent.


    http://justicekatju.blogspot.com/2016/01/bengalis-and-bose-i-hold-bengalis-in.html


    At this, one of the High Court Judges, who was a Bengali, reacted almost hysterically, and started shouting at me, and threatening to walk out. I was taken aback, and had to apologise, as I did not want the party to be broken up.


    But I have witnessed a somewhat similar reaction by many ( not all ) Bengalis if one speaks against Tagore. It is sometimes impossible to talk rationally with many Bengalis about ‘Netaji’ and Tagore.


    Are Subhas Chandra Bose and Tagore the private property of Bengalis ? Can no one criticize them in the presence of Bengalis ? If Bengalis regard them as public figures, not the private property of Bengalis, then the public surely has the right to assess and criticize them.


    I have expressed my views about Bose and Tagore on my blog justicekatju.blogspot.in and I do not intend to repeat them in detail.


    https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/india/now-katju-calls-bose-japanese-agent-tagore-british-stooge/articleshow/48963085.cms


    I regard Tagore as a British stooge who was promoted by Yeats ( who got him a Nobel Prize ), and used by the British to divert literature from the revolutionary direction Sharad Chandra Chattopadhyaya and Kazi Nazrul Islam were taking it ( see Sharad Chandra’s novel ‘ Pather Dabi’, which was banned by the British. At one time the price of one copy was the same as that of a Mauser pistol ).


    See in this connection my article ‘ The Role of Art and Literature ‘ on my blog.


    I have explained there that there are broadly two theories of art and literature, one is called ‘Art for art’s sake’, and the other is called ‘ Art for social purpose ‘. In a poor country like India only the second theory is acceptable.


    Tagore belonged broadly to the school of ‘ Art for Art’s sake’, propagating spiritualism and mystical nonsense ( see his poems ‘Gitanjali’, ‘Agni beena bajao tumi kemon kore’, ‘Klanti’, etc ), while Sharad Chandra and Kazi Nazrul Islam belonged to the school of ‘ Art for social purpose’.

    The British were scared of the writings of Sharad Chandra, as they could inspire an anti-British Indian freedom struggle, and so they promoted their stooge Tagore who diverted Bengali literature to a harmless, spiritual direction.
    Am I not entitled to even present my view about Tagore before Bengalis ? Do I not have freedom of expression ?


    As regard Bose, I regard him as a Japanese agent, otherwise why did he give up the struggle against the British in 1945 when the Japanese surrendered ? If he was a real freedom fighter he should have carried on a guerilla war against the British, as the Chinese had done against the Japanese. In a guerilla war one fights with the weapons of the enemy, by snatching them from the enemy.


    As a young man, Bose was no doubt full of patriotism, because of which he resigned from the ICS and joined the freedom struggle. However, it seems later in life he became ambitious. After Gandhi forced him to resign from Presidentship of the Congress in 1939, he became frustrated, and at first went to Nazi Germany where he hobnobbed with Hitler and Himmler, two of the most evil men in world history, seeking their help to fight the British. When that scheme did not work out, he went to Japan, whose rulers helped him raise the INA.


    In fact Bose was only being used by the Japanese Imperialists, who would have bumped him off once his utility was over, or made him a puppet ruler of India, like Pu Yi, who was a puppet ruler of Manchukuo.


    https://www.britannica.com/biography/Puyi


    Would the Japanese fascists have given freedom to India if they had defeated the British ? Not at all, they were fascist imperialists, seeking markets and raw materials, and if they had conquered India would have looted it, and slaughtered a lot of Indians, the way they looted Manchuria and North China under their occupation, and slaughtered tens of thousands of Chinese in Nanking, Shanghai, etc. ( see on Youtube about these massacres ).


    Many Bengalis and others support Bose, as they believe he was right since an enemy’s enemy was one’s friend. They forget this dictum cannot be of universal application. Making an alliance with India’s enemy’s enemy i.e. Japan, would have been good if it would have benefited us. But as I have pointed out above, if Japan had conquered India they would not have given us freedom, but would have made India their colony, and looted us, perhaps much more ruthlessly than the British ( since they were fascists ).


    I have great respect for Bengalis, many of whom are my close friends. I would only request them to react rationally and ponder about what I have said, instead of reacting emotionally, treating Bose and Tagore like holy cows

  • What kind of army is this ?

    What kind of army is this ?


    By Justice Katju


    At a recent meeting of the Pakistan Corps Commanders Conference held at the army headquarters in Rawalpindi, chaired by the army chief Gen Munir, the generals decided to support the government’s revival plan for the Pakistan economy.

    What kind of army is this ?


    https://t.co/eBb9b7jNHx


    Among the things discussed were the army’s role in uplifting agriculture, information technology, mines and minerals and defence production sectors under the Special Investment Facilitation Council (SIFC).


    Now a question immediately arises : what has the army got to do with the economy ? That is surely the job of the civilian government. An army’s job is to protect the country’s border, and help in dealing with internal disturbance if called upon to do so by the civilian authorities.


    The Pakistan army is unique in the world in this respect. It meddles with everything in Pakistan, which no army in the world has any business to do, e.g. the economy ( which it has looted ), the judiciary (whose orders are not obeyed at its instance ), the police ( whom it has ordered arresting of thousands of Pakistanis and all kinds of atrocities on them ), etc.


    It has been hounding former Prime Minister Imran Khan because he dared to criticise former army chief Gen Bajwa and the Inter Services Public Relations (ISPR ) Director General Maj Gen Ahmed Sharif Chaudhry, although that is a right of citizens in every democratic country, since the army is not a holy cow which cannot be criticised. Senior PTI leaders are mostly under arrest or are underground, and the army’s effort is to debar PTI and Imran Khan from contesting the forthcoming elections, although the vast majority ( may be 90% ) of Pakistanis support Imran Khan.


    https://thenewscaravan.com/why-are-pakistan-generals-so-hostile-to-imran-khan/


    Is this an army or a bunch of American mafia type gangsters ?

    I have given details of their loot


    https://www.theweek.in/news/india/2019/08/26/opinion-the-truth-about-the-pakistan-military.html


    Evidently the Pakistani generals have learnt nothing from history


    https://writerscafeteria.com/guest-blogging/have-they-learnt-nothing-from-history/

  • Moharram and Holi on same day By Justice Katju

    Moharram and Holi on same day By Justice Katju


    Tomorrow, 19th July, is the beginning of Moharram, an important day for Muslims, particularly Shias.


    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Muharram#:~:text=Mu%E1%B8%A5arram%20(Arabic%3A%20%D9%B1%D9%84%D9%92%D9%85%D9%8F%D8%AD%D9%8E%D8%B1%D9%8E%D9%91%D9%85)%20(,Muharram

    In this connection I may recount a recorded incident.
    Once in the 1840s or 1850s Holi and Muharram fell coincidentally on the same day.


    The then Nawab of Avadh, Wajid Ali Shah was a Shia.


    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wajid_Ali_Shah


    After taking out the tazia from the Bada Imambara and burying it in the Karbala in Lucknow, he enquired why Holi was not being celebrated.

    Moharram and Holi on same day By Justice Katju


    He was told that since Holi was a festival of joy, while Muharram was an occasion of sorrow, the Hindus of Avadh had decided not to celebrate Holi that year, out of respect for the sentiments of their Muslim brethren.
    On hearing this the Nawab declared that since Hindus had respected the sentiments of their Muslim brethren, it was the duty of Muslims also to respect the sentiments of their Hindu brethren. He then announced that Holi would be celebrated the same day throughout Avadh, and he himself was the first to play Holi, and it was played throughout Avadh that day ( even by Muslims ), although it was also Muharram day.

  • Lies, damned lies, and statistics

    Lies, damned lies, and statistics

    By Justice Katju

    An article by Justice Markandey Katju

     Discrepancies and Doubts Surrounding India's Poverty Statistics: A Deeper Look


    An article titled ‘Over 135 Million Indians Break Free from Multidimensional Poverty in Five Years, States NITI Aayog Report ‘ has been published in the portal thenewscaravan.com


    https://thenewscaravan.com/over-135-million-indians-break-free-from-multidimensional-poverty-in-five-years-states-niti-aayog-report/


    There are two problems accepting this assertion (1) The source is Niti Aaayog, a Govt of India body, which would naturally like to paint a rosy picture of the country (2) Statistics in India are highly questionable, as it is very difficult to verify them.
    There is an aphorism of Mark Twain ” iies, damned lies, and statistics ”.


    https://www.forbes.com/sites/kalevleetaru/2017/02/02/lies-damned-lies-and-statistics-how-bad-statistics-are-feeding-fake-news/


    This aphorism squarely applies to India, as it is a pretty disorganised country. Moreover it is so vast,, with 1400 million people, that it is difficult to get accurate figures, often even by a neutral unbiased body, what to say of a Government of India agency. How many people are poor, how many unemployed, how many lack proper healthcare and good education, etc are impossible to verify accurately, or even to conjecture.


    And what is the definition of poverty ? Since prices of essential commodities have steeply escalated in India in recent years, and incomes have not correspondingly increased ( assuming they have increased at all ), it is obvious that poverty has increased ( since incomes are relative to the price index ).

    india's Poverty by justice katju


    https://energy.economictimes.indiatimes.com/news/oil-and-gas/steep-rise-in-prices-of-essential-commodities-burning-a-hole-in-common-mans-pocket/96557653


    https://scroll.in/article/1023709/explained-how-the-prices-of-essentials-have-soared-in-india-over-the-past-decade


    Global Hunger Index, which is a reputed international agency reporting on world hunger, reported that half of Indian children are malnourished, wasted and/or stunted. India (which has a population of 1400 million ) has slipped from position number 101 to 107 in just one year ( 2021-2022 ) among the 121 countries surveyed by that international agency

    https://byjus.com/free-ias-prep/global-hunger-index/#:~:text=India%20ranks%20107th%20out%20of,countries%20covered%20in%20the%20GHI.

    Over 55% of our women are anaemic

    https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/education/news/46-of-girls-under-15-anaemic-in-india-report/articleshow/89098690.cms

    Tens of millions of our young men and women are without jobs? If 100 class 4 ( peon or unskilled manual labour ) govt jobs are advertised, there are often several hundred thousand applicants, many of them having M.Sc M.A., or M.B.A. degrees ( some even Ph.D. ), engineers, etc.

    https://economictimes.indiatimes.com/news/politics-and-nation/over-93000-candidates-including-3700-phd-holders-apply-for-peon-job-in-up/articleshow/65604396.cms

    https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/education/news/8-lakh-apply-for-4400-jobs-advertised-by-maharashtra-govt/articleshow/67911127.cms

    Proper healthcare and good education is almost non-existent for the masses. Private hospitals and clinics are too expensive for the masses, and the condition of the govt ones is terrible (to say the least ). Even the All India Instititute of Medical Sciences ), New Delhi ( AIIMS ), a premier Indian medical institute, looks like a railway station, with thousands of sick people waiting outside endlessly, and usually with perfunctory care, if any. The condition of most schools in India is terrible.

    It is sometimes claimed that GDP in India is growing, but no one asks who is getting the fruits of that growth, the Indian masses, or just a handful of big businessmen and international corporates ? The gap between rich and poor has widened in India, with a handful of big businessmen becoming richer ( often by illegal means ) while the poor get poorer ( because of escalating prices of food, etc ).

    Oxfam India’s report directly contradicts the report of Niti Aayog

    https://www.guwahatiplus.com/oxfam-india-highlights-widening-gap-between-indias-rich-and-poor#:~:text=GUWAHATI%3A%20A%20report%20by%20Oxfam,3%25%20of%20the%20country’s%20wealth.

    https://www.oxfam.org/en/india-extreme-inequality-numbers

    Other sources also contradict Niti Aayog’s claim.

    https://www.cnn.com/interactive/2017/10/world/i-on-india-income-gap/

    https://thewire.in/economy/india-world-inequality-report-poor-affluent-elite-progress

    https://www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-india-64286673

    https://www.news9live.com/opinion-blogs/rich-poor-gap-in-india-has-become-wider-in-terms-of-wealth-distribution-165312

    So whom is one to believe ? One’s mind boggles.

  • The importance of Urdu poetry in today’s India

    The importance of Urdu poetry in today’s India


    By Justice Katju

    The Need for Literature in Times of Transformation


    Urdu Poetry : I have repeatedly said that the next 10-20 years in Indian history will be a turbulent, stormy period which will culminate in creating a new political and social order, under which India rapidly modernises and industrialises, the great evils of poverty, unemployment, child malnutrition, lack of proper healthcare and good education, etc which plague our country today, are largely abolished, and our people get decent lives.
    In this stormy period great literature will be required, to attack feudal forces like casteism and communalism, and inspire people to perform heroic deeds, sometimes even at the cost of one’s lives.This period will witness a mighty united people’s struggle, which will be protracted, arduous, with many twists and turns, and in which tremendous sacrifices will have to be made.

    Historical Examples: Literature’s Role in Inspiring Change


    For instance, the writings of Voltaire and Rousseau which attacked feudalism and religious bigotry, inspired the people of France and led to the overthrow of the monarchy and the great French Revolution of 1789 which destroyed feudalism in France.. Similarly, the writings of Thomas Paine ( e.g. ‘Commonsense’ ) inspired the patriots in the American War of Independence (1775-81 ). The writings of Maxim Gorki ( see his novel ‘Mother’ and his poem ‘Song of the Stormy Petrel’ ) inspired the Russian people and their Revolution in 1917.

    Urdu poetry like Bismil’s poem ‘Sarfaroshi ki tamanna ab hamaare dil mein hai’ inspired India’s freedom struggle, and Faiz’ poem ‘Hum dekhenge’ inspired Pakistanis in their fight against military dictatorship.
    I submit that Urdu poetry ( in its simplified, and not highly Persianised, form ), will be of great utility to the Indian people in this turbulent period.

    Urdu poetry like Bismil's poem 'Sarfaroshi ki tamanna ab hamaare dil mein hai' inspired India's freedom struggle, and Faiz' poem 'Hum dekhenge' inspired Pakistanis in their fight against military dictatorship.


    https://indicanews.com/2023/01/03/justice-katju-the-power-of-urdu-poetry/


    https://www.facebook.com/justicekatju/posts/urdu-poetry-is-a-shining-gem-in-the-treasury-of-indian-culture-those-who-speak-d/1019854461388433/

    http://justicekatju.blogspot.com/2012/02/role-of-art-literature-and-media.html


    This is because of the dual nature of Urdu, as explained in my article ‘What is Urdu’.


    http://justicekatju.blogspot.com/2012/02/what-is-urdu-speech-delivered-on-8.html



    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Voltairehttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jean-Jacques_Rousseau

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Common_Sense

    https://www.facebook.com/justicekatju/posts/the-song-of-the-stormy-petrel-the-song-of-the-stormy-petrel-see-online-was-a-poe/2624834550890408/

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9AhYiokgBW4&pp=ygU6c2FyZmFyb3NoaSBraSB0YW1hbm5hIGFiIGhhbWFyZSBkaWwgbWUgaGFpIGxhdGEgbWFuZ2VzaGthcg%3D%3D

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jV7rSX-wZLA&pp=ygUcaHVtIGRla2hlbmdlIGZhaXogYWhtZWQgZmFpeg%3D%3D

    Urdu Poetry: A Unique Blend of Languages and Elegance

    As explained therein, Urdu is a language created by a combination of two languages (1) Hindustani or khadiboli and (2) Persian. That is why at one time it was called Rekhta, which means hybrid. While the former is the language of the common man in large parts of urban India even today, the latter was the language of the aristocratic elite in India for centuries during Mughal rule and even thereafter.


    Thus while Urdu is the language of the common man ( since its base is Hindustani, as its verbs are all in Hindustani ), it has also the sophistication and polish of an aristocrat, since Persian was the language of aristocrats. While the content of Urdu poetry is the feelings, sorrows, and aspirations of the common man, they are expressed not exactly in the language of the common man, but in a somewhat aristocratic and sophisticated manner, which gives it great power and elegance.

    Power and Elegance of Urdu Poetry Compared to Hindi


    Take for instance Bismil’s verse ‘Sarfaroshi ki tamanna ab hamaare dil mein hai’. If we write this in Hindi it will become ‘Sheesh katwaane ki manokaamna ab hamaare hriday mein hai’. Does this have the power and elegance of the former ? It does not.
    Or take Faiz’ verse ‘Bol ki lab azad hain tere, bol zubaan ab tak teri hai’. In Hindi this becomes ‘Uchchaaran karo ki onth swatantra hain tumhaare, uchchaaran karo ki jivha ab tak tumhaari hai’. Does this have the power and elegance of the former ? It does not.


    I am not against Hindi. It is my mother tongue, so how can I be against it ? But the truth is that modern Hindi poetry does not have the power and elegance which Urdu poetry has.

    Urdu Poetry as a Tool for Protest and Expression


    In fact in many agitations and protests in India students recited and sang Faiz’ poem ‘Hum Dekhenge’ and Habib Jalib’s poem ‘Main nahi maanta’ and ‘Hukmaraan ho gaye kameene log’


    https://indianexpress.com/article/trending/trending-in-india/students-singing-faiz-ahmads-hum-dekhenge-at-14000ft-goes-viral-6200607/


    https://www.facebook.com/InUthdotcom/videos/iimc-students-sing-faiz-ahmad-faizs-hum-dekhenge-in-unison/540881886637606/


    https://www.facebook.com/100076276022943/videos/indian-students-at-jnu-are-singing-habib-jalibs-famous-poem-dastoor/1345625812254719/


    The Journey of Revolution: Toiling through Challenges

    I conclude with my own sher ( couplet ) :
    ‘Hum inquilaabiyon ko naya jahaan banaana hai magar
    Yeh safar hai mashaqqat-o-museebaten liye hue’
    i.e.
    We, revolutionaries, have to create a new world
    But this journey is full of toil and difficulties

  • Seema Haider – The Modern Helen of Troy By Justice Katju

    Seema Haider – The Modern Helen of Troy By Justice Katju


    It is an old custom in India ( and the world ) that a lady in love is carried away by her lover, ( usually with her consent ).


    Many young women want some handsome young knight, preferably in shining armour riding a charger, to come to them and carry them away.
    This is the way how Lord Krishna carried away Rukmini ( whom he later married ) on a chariot.


    https://back2godhead.com/the-kidnapping-of-princess-rukmini/


    This happened to Helen of Troy, who though married, was carried away by her lover Paris ( which is what she wanted ), which triggered off the Trojan War, depicted by Homer.


    It happened in England when Queen Guinevere was carried away by her lover, Sir Lancelot, Knight of King Arthur’s Round Table, though she was married to King Arthur.


    It happened in Rajasthan when Princess Sanyogita, daughter of King Jaichand, was carried away by her lover Prithviraj, the enemy of Jaichand ( which is what she wanted ).


    And now it has happened in the Indian subcontinent, when a married Pakistani woman with 4 children, Seema Haider, has run away with an Indian man, Sachin Meena, via Dubai and Nepal to India, where they are currently living in Noida with her children.


    Discounting the allegations that Seema is a spy, and taking her words that she is genuinely in love with Sachin at their face value, these incidents prove the truth in Urdu poet Mirza Ghalib’s sher ( couplet ) :


    ” Ishq par zor nahi hai yeh woh aatish Ghalib
    Ki lagaaye na lage, aur bujhaaye na bujhe ” :
    i.e.
    ” There is no coercion in love, it is that flame
    Which cannot be forcibly lit, nor extinguished once lit ”.


    I am reminded of a song I sang myself some time back in a wedding :


    https://www.facebook.com/justicekatju/videos/704287491294413/


    And this is one of my favourite songs


    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qRPPob2BQLU&pp=ygUnYWdhciB0dW0gbWlsIGphbyBqYW1hbmEgY2hob2QgZGVuZ2UgaGFt

  • Kalidas Ghalib Academy By Justice Katju

    Kalidas Ghalib Academy By Justice Katju


    We have to transform India into a modern highly industrialised country in which all our people enjoy a high standard of living and decent lives.
    For this three organisations have been created (1) Ibaadatkhana (2) Indian Reunification Association (IRA) and (3) Kalidas Ghalib Academy
    While the first two are active, the third, which was once active, but has been inactive for quite some time, needs to be reactivated.

    https://thenewscaravan.com/the-need-for-reviving-and-revamping-kalidas-ghalib-foundation-by-justice-katju/

    https://thenewscaravan.com/what-should-indian-muslims-do/

    Powerful divisive forces have started operating in our country trying to sow the seeds of discord among our people and creating hatred and enmity between various communities and groups.
    In this scenario the time has now come for the patriotic intellectuals of our country to come forward to give guidance to the people, combat communalism and casteism, and to promote the rich composite culture of India and help the country on the path of progress.

    It is with this aim and intention that the Kalidas-Ghalib Academy ( of which I am the patron, and Naushad Ali Syed is the Chairman ) has been created.

    While all the three organisations mentioned above have the common goal of making India ( which includes Pakistan and Bangladesh, for we are really one nation only temporarily and artificially divided ) a prosperous modern country, the Kalidas Ghalib Academy operates in the fields of culture, art and literature.

    In the great historical people’s struggle which lies ahead of us art and literature can play a significant role in inspiring people to heroic deeds and attacking backward feudal customs and ideas like casteism and communalism, as was done by great writers like Voltaire and Rousseau ( who attacked the feudal system and religious bigotry in France before the great French Revolution of 1789, Thomas Paine in the great American War of Independence ( see his pamphlet ‘Commonsense’ ), Maxim Gorki in Czarist Russia ( see his novel ‘Mother’ and his poem ‘Song of the Stormy Petrel’ ), Bismil’s poem ‘Sarfaroshi ki tamanna ab hamaare dil mein hai’ and Faiz’ poem ‘Hum dekhenge’ etc

    I discussed with Naushad and we agreed that we need a team of younger people to run the organisation ( I am 77 and Naushad is 75 ), while we oversee its activities from above.

    My appeal is to people who have some connection with culture, art and literature, and who may be interested in being members of this team, to write to me on justicekatju@gmail.com or Naushad on naushadalisyed@gmail.com. Only those who can devote some time to this historical endeavour, and strongly believe in secularism and promotion of the Ganga-Jamuna tehzeeb ( composite culture of India ) need apply

  • Today, 14th July, is Bastille Day.

    Today, 14th July, is Bastille Day.

    Bastille Day
    By Justice Katju

    On 14th July 1789 Parisians stormed and destroyed the Bastille, a French prison fort, which symbolised the feudal Ancient Regime, and the French people set about destroying feudalism and creating a modern nation.


    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bastille_Day


    Similarly, the Indian people ( which includes Pakistanis and Bangladeshis ) have to storm and destroy the feudal forces of casteism, communalism and superstitions, and create a political and social order under which we emerge as a mighty modern highly industrialised nation in which all our people enjoy a high standard of living and decent lives.


    But while the Bastille was destroyed in one day, we can accomplish our goal only after a protracted, united, arduous struggle, transcending the feudal barriers of caste, religion, race, etc, and lasting for perhaps 10-15 years, in which tremendous sacrifices will have to be made.


    Unity of our people is absolutely essential at this historical juncture

    .
    https://writerscafeteria.com/guest-blogging/unity-of-indians-is-absolutely-essential-at-this-historical-juncture/


    This is because while the French people had only to fight against a weak king ( Louis 16th ) we have powerful forces, both within and outside our country, which will oppose tooth and nail the radical transformation of India into a modern industrial giant, and this they do by polarising our society and inciting religious, caste and ethnic hatred among us.


    https://indicanews.com/2023/02/22/the-puppeteer-and-the-puppets/


    But without this transformation, this Great Leap Forward, we will remain condemned to massive poverty, unemployment, malnutrition, lack of proper healthcare and good education for the masses,and the other great socio-economic evils which plague our country.


    https://indicanews.com/2020/10/15/india-needs-a-great-leap-forward/


    https://indicanews.com/2023/05/07/justice-markandey-katju-india-the-sleeping-giant-will-awake/


    So, (paraphrasing Winston Churchill’s words on the eve of the Battle of Britain) let us brace ourselves to our duty, and so bear ourselves, that if the Indian nation lasts for another thousand years, men will still say ” This was their finest hour ”.