Tag: Justice Markandey Katju

  • How my team won a cricket match

    How my team won a cricket match


    By Justice Katju


    When I was in Allahabad I used to play for a cricket team,
    Once we played against a rival team and were all out for 1 run.
    Naturally we were feeling very despondent, and thought the match was over.
    Seeing our crestfallen faces the umpire came over to us and asked why we were feeling so sad.


    We told him we had lost the match.
    He said ” Why do you worry ? I am here. All you have to do is that when your bowler bowls the ball all of you shout together ‘How’s that’, and leave the rest to me ”.
    So when our bowler bowled the first ball, which was promptly despatched by the batsman to the boundary, we all shouted in unison ” How’s that ”.


    The umpire immediately lifted up his forefinger, and declared the batsman out.
    ” How out ? ” asked the furious batsman, enraged by the umpire’s decision.
    ” Judgment is judgment ” said the umpire, with a deadpan countenance, and the batsman sheepishly left the field.


    The same thing happened when our bowler bowled the next ball to the batsman who followed, and to the one’s who came thereafter.
    In this way our rival team was all out for 0, and we won the match.

  • A meeting with some Americans: Justice Katju

    A meeting with some Americans: Justice Katju


    Some time back a group of 15 or 16 Americans came from USA to India. They were all white, half of them women.
    Someone organised a meeting between them and me in Delhi.


    When we sat together I mentioned in my address to them that the condition of blacks of USA was fairly good.


    At this most of them vociferously disagreed ( though they were themselves all white ).
    I then asked them ” How many of you have read Mark Twain’s novel ‘Adventures of Huckleberry Finn ? ”.


    This is a truly great American novel, and Ernest Hemingway, himself a great novelist, often said that all American literature begins with that single novel. However it was at one time banned in some places in America because of its alleged racist slurs, particularly use of the word ‘nigger’ which is today regarded very offensive in America.


    Only a few of the group said that they had read it.
    I then related a scene in that novel when there is an explosion, and Aunt Sally ( a middle aged character in the novel ) said on hearing about it ” My God ! Was anyone hurt ? ”. To which Huck replies ” No Ma’am, only a nigger killed ”.


    Having said that I said that this indicates that before the Civil War in America ( 1861-65 ) which abolished slavery blacks were not even regarded humans, and could be even killed by their masters.


    Their degradation continued for a long time even after the Civil War, with Black Codes, Jim Crow laws, frequent lynchings of blacks by the Ku Klux Klan and others, denial of voting rights, etc.

    Though legally emancipated from slavery, most of them remained very poor and with little education.
    Racial segregation was legally upheld by the infamous decision of the US Supreme Court in Plessy vs Ferguson (1896) which laid down the devious principle of ‘separate but equal’.

    As a result there was racial apartheid in America ( as in South Africa ), and there were segregated schools, hotels, restaurants, hospitals, cinema theatres, public transportation in buses and trains, housing locations, swimming pools, sports, etc. In many states ( particularly in the south ) interracial marriages were legally prohibited ( as in Nazi Germany ), and in many areas blacks were not allowed to enter, e.g. in many beaches in Florida.
    However, in 1954 the US Supreme Court in Brown vs Board of Education reversed the Plessy verdict, and a few years later laws made by the US Congress like the Civil Rights Act, 1964, the Voting Rights Act, 1965, the Fair Housing Act, 1968 etc considerably improved the conditions of blacks in America.


    Now blacks cannot be legally discriminated against, and many of them have risen to high positions e.g. Barack Obama who became President of USA in 2009 and was reelected in 2012. Many blacks are today highly educated. Many are in the US Congress, many are successful businessmen and businesswomen, scientists, doctors, engineers, artists etc
    Of course there is still some prejudice and discrimination against blacks in some areas in USA, particularly in the south, and a few incidents from time to time like killing of a black man, George Floyd by a white policeman in Minneapolis, Minnesota in 2020 which resulted in widespread protests in America, even by whites.


    However, I asked the group I was addressing, can there be any doubt that the condition of blacks has considerably improved since the days of slavery ? Today a black man who has sex with or marries a white girl will not be killed, unlike in India where for a dalit boy to fall in love with or marrying a non-dalit girl is often inviting a death sentence ( called honour killing )


    Having said all this, I told the group that like people of all countries, Americans too have made mistakes in the past. But they later realised their mistakes, and rectified them. There is no doubt that America is a great country, and Americans have made great contributions in science, technology, and other fields which have benefited the whole world.


    Having concluded my speech, I said ” Long live America ! ”.

  • Muslims have a right to take out Tazia during Muharram: Justice Katju

    Muslims have a right to take out Tazia during Muharram: Justice Katju


    Muharram, a period of mourning for Muslims over the martyrdom of Imam Husain, grandson of Prophet Muhammad, is going on these days ( today is the 8th day of a 10 day period which will end on 29th July )


    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Muharram


    https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/religion/festivals/muharram-2023-date-story-and-significance-of-ashura/articleshow/101819083.cms#:~:text=In%202023%2C%20Muharram%20commenced%20on%20Wednesday%2C%2019th%20July%202023.&text=Muharram%20holds%20an%20immense%20importance,remembrance%20for%20the%20Muslim%20Ummah.


    On the last (10th) day of Muharram, known as Ashura, Muslims take out the Tazia procession to bury the Tazia ( a replica of the mausoleum of Imam Husain ) at a ground called Karbala ( named after the city in Iraq where Imam Husain and others were martyred in 680 AD ).


    https://www.ndtv.com/india-news/muharram-2022-know-why-tazia-are-made-and-its-significance-3236669


    In this connection I may refer to a judgment on the Tazia procession which I gave in 1999 when I was a Judge of the Allahabad High Court ( Imambara of Mulnapur vs State of UP )


    https://legaldata.in/court/read/1576550


    The facts were these : there is an Imambara ( the building from where the Tazia procession is taken out ) in village Mulnapur, Tehsil Handia, district Allahabad. Every year Muslims of the area would take out the Tazia in a procession on the 10th day of Muharram for its burial at Karbala.


    However, in 1999 some anti social elements allegedly obstructed the path of the Tazia procession by occupying and constructing unauthorisedly on it, and hence a writ petition was filed before me.


    After hearing the parties I allowed the petition, observing :
    ” This is a free, democratic, and secular country. Article 25(1) of the Constitution states ‘subject to public order, morality and health and to the other provisions of this part all persons are equally entitled to freedom of conscience and the right freely to profess, practice and propagate religion’.
    Tazia is a part of Muslim religion and Muslims are fully entitled to take out Tazia procession. Hence, we direct that there should be no obstruction and the authorities will ensure law and order in peaceful taking out of Tazia.


    However, we have repeatedly held that religion is a private affair and must be carried out peacefully without causing harm or harassment to anybody, and hence Tazia cannot be taken out through the private land of anybody. It can only be taken out peacefully on a public path and in a manner which does not cause inconvenience to anybody. The path of the Tazia has been recommended by the S.D.M., Handia and the map is Annexure-2 to the petition. The petitioner is agreeable to this path suggested by the S.D.M.

    Hence, we are of the opinion that the Tazia procession can be taken over on the aforesaid path as suggested by the S.D.M., Handia, Allahabad but we direct that no private property or trees should be damaged during the course of Tazia procession.

    The petitioner and the authorities will also maintain law and order.
    With these directions the petition is finally disposed of ”.

  • A Problem I addressed: Justice Katju

    A Problem I addressed: Justice Katju


    By Justice Katju


    I sometimes use my status as a former Indian Supreme Court Judge to help people in distress. An example is given below.


    Recently I had been invited to Mapappuram in Kerala in a function. Before the function some people informed me of an acute problem youth faced here.


    It appears that students who pass the class 10 examination, many with 90-95% marks, cannot get admission in class 11 in science, engineering, computers or pre-medical courses, because of a great shortage of seats in colleges.


    When I reached the jam packed hall where the function was held and came on the dias I found sitting next to me the Speaker of the Kerala Legislative Assembly, Mr AN Shamseer, many MLAs of different political parties, etc

    1000011168


    When my turn came to speak I spoke mainly about the above problem. I turned towards the politicians sitting in the front row and said ” This problem should have been solved by you politicians. If you cannot you are no good, resign and go home. You are destroying the lives of these young people, who should become scientists, engineers, IT experts, doctors, etc It is a crime you are committing. If you dont solve the problem I will personally come in the next elections and canvass against you. Please inform the Chief Minister of Kerala Mr Vijayan about what I said ”.


    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iJupmbVwvSE&pp=ygUMa2F0anUga2VyYWxh


    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZuW2FgoZONQ&pp=ygVDanVzdGljZSBrYXRqdSBkZW1hbmRzIG1vcmUgc2VhdHMgZm9yIHBsdXMgMTAgc3R1ZGVudHMgaW4gbWFsYXBwdXJhbQ%3D%3D


    There was huge applause at this, and the next day my speech was widely reported on TV and the newspapers.


    https://l.facebook.com/l.php?u=https%3A%2F%2Ftimesofindia.indiatimes.com%2Fcity%2Fkozhikode%2Fquit-if-you-cant-solve-issue-katju%2Farticleshow%2F101680732.cms%3Ffbclid%3DIwAR0pfjGccmRxPcM2310nI6FuKX90R6T9Lv2SOU1ogLZqQtL_Yhd3sZMcCgk&h=AT00OVeAuiKmSPFE3uk5bOt8Zym3BkqdmXFLOFHBTj7JyLV5Yh_qLXriiKQIn_mpkJmjQQT3vfEVeM9UpLjyuebXeE-IY3S9jDLqI0aNvBZVByh-ocVlpXg5AHFCbmZhcLWv5L_Q9mv-3wh4TpfD&tn=-UK-R&c[0]=AT0liBG8FLOc0FNvnCcsn_YbqtlMNxzxuFnCW6znMX7nahCbpGzkqPZ9-fjWtwT9G-plZfpsKdKI5oyU4_sgkkQr86US4dpmIiuAqS2Jc_-ZE7ovfj5pnsE55tcRjej__eLpef-gSZIe8SRHVEBlIQ_m2G_L_4Sf0X0e8Dp_KVZHraspg6hstPaBES0nNsj1zMT4FmA-IvQc


    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kr60vUXUc_Q


    The Speaker said he will convey my demand to the Chief Minister.
    On my return home I sent an email to the Chief Minister repeating my demand, and calling him to resign if he cant solve the problem.


    https://english.janamtv.com/news/kerala/64069/markandeya-katju-urges-pinarayi-vijayan-to-resign/


    Yesterday I got the good news that the Kerala Govt has acceded to my request, and has announced considerable increase in the number of plus 10 seats


    https://www.newindianexpress.com/states/kerala/2023/jul/26/plus-one-seat-shortage-in-kerala-cabinet-announces-97-newbatches-2598805.html


    https://www.thehindu.com/news/national/kerala/nod-for-97-temporary-plus-one-batches-for-malabar/article67123945.ece


    https://english.mathrubhumi.com/education/news/plus-one-admission-sivankutty-announces-97-additional-batches-in-malabar-1.8763324


    Now I am just a retired person, with no power or authority. But I suppose my being a former Supreme Court Judge gives me some muscle, and that seems to have shaken up the Kerala govt
    I am happy I was of some use to the people of Kerala

  • Urdu shaayari should be banned in Pakistan : Justice Katju

    Urdu shaayari should be banned in Pakistan : Justice Katju


    By Justice Katju
    Urdu shaayari should be banned as being unislamic in the Islamic Republic of Pakistan.
    What else should be done to a poetry whose greatest poet Mirza Ghalib writes :
    ” Masjid ke zer-e-saaya kharaabaat chaahiye ”
    i.e.
    ” Below a mosque there should be a wine shop ”
    ( Wine is haraam or strictly prohibited in Islam ).
    Or consider this sher of Ghalib :
    ” Imaan mjujhe roke hai jo khainche hai mujhe kufr
    Kaaba mere peeche hai, kaleesa mere aage ”
    i.e.
    ” Faith is holding me back, disbelief in islam is pulling me forward
    I have turned my back on the Kaaba, and looking towards the church ”
    Or this sher by Ghalib :
    ” Kahaan maikhaane ka darwaza Ghalib aur kahaan waiz
    Par itna jaante hain kal vo jaata tha ki hum nikle ”
    i.e.
    ” A pub and a religious scholar are poles apart
    But yesterday when I entered the pub he was leaving ”
    Consider this sher ( couplet ) of Mir Taqi Mir, another great Urdu poet :
    ” Mir ke deen-o-mazhab ko poochte kya ho, unne to
    Kashka kheencha dair mein baitha kab ka tark Islam kiya ”.
    i.e.
    ” Why do you ask Mir’s religion ?
    He has put on a tika ( mark on the forehead which Hindus make ), and sat in a
    Hindu temple
    And renounced Islam long ago ”
    And what about this sher of the Urdu poet Aatish :
    ” Fasl-e-bahaar aayi piyo sufiyon sharaab
    Bas ho chuki namaaz musalla uthaiye ”
    i.e.
    ” The crop of spring has come, so Sufis drink wine
    The namaaz is over, pick up the prayer carpet ( and drink ) ”
    Another Urdu poet Sahir Ludhianvi writes :
    ” Aqaayad waham hai, mazhab khyaal-e-khaam hai saaqi
    Azal se zehn-e-insaan basta-e-auhaam hai saaqi ”
    i.e.
    ” Faiths are illusions, and religion is false imagination
    Since eternity man’s mind has been bound by superstitions ”.
    Numerous such examples of apostasy and blasphemy in Urdu poetry by well known poets can be given.
    So I urge the Pakistan Parliament and Govt to quickly ban Urdu mushairas and study of Urdu poetry in educational institutions, and burn all Urdu poetry books, and declare all those who read or recite Urdu poetry as ‘murtads’ deserving the punishment meted out to murtads in Islam

  • The Manipur Govt must be sacked immediately : Justice Katju

    The Manipur Govt must be sacked immediately : Justice Katju


    Today I met in Delhi two Professors of a University in Manipur. They told me they are here in Delhi because their University is closed down sine die.due to the violence in Manipur.


    Since I did not know what exactly happened in Manipur, I requested them to explain to me. They said they will do so on condition that their names be not disclosed. This is what they said :
    In Manipur most people who live in the plains are Hindus, who support the BJP Govt of Manipur whose Chief Minister is Biren Singh. On the other hand, the people living in the hills around the plains in Manipur are Nagas and Kukis who are Christians, and are treated as Scheduled Tribes (STs ).


    The Meiteis are economically better off as compared to Nagas and Kukis, and are better educated and have greater political representation in the state assembly.
    There is a law in the state of Manipur which says that Meiteis cannot buy land in the hills, which are reserved for STs i.e. Nagas and Kukis. Also, certain seats in educational institutions and govt jobs are reserved for the STs.


    The trouble began when a single judge, the Acting Chief Justice of Manipur High Court, Justice Muralidaran passed an order that the state govt should consider including Meiteis among the Scheduled Tribes


    https://m.economictimes.com/news/politics-and-nation/manipur-high-court-order-to-include-meiteis-in-st-list-rrong-cji/articleshow/100312542.cms


    https://thewire.in/law/supreme-court-manipur-hc-meitei-scheduled-tribes-list


    https://scroll.in/latest/1049253/manipur-high-court-order-on-scheduled-tribe-status-for-meiteis-is-factually-wrong-says-sc


    An appeal was filed in the Supreme Court against this order, but the Supreme Court, while expressing its displeasure, did not stay the order, perhaps because an appeal had been filed against it before a two judge bench of the High Court, where it is pending.


    Justice Muralidaran’s order raised an apprehension in the minds of the Kukis and Nagas that their lands in the hills will be grabbed by Meiteis, and that Meiteis will get a share in admissions to educational institutions and govt jobs reserved for STs like Kukis and Nagas.

    https://www.reuters.com/world/india/why-is-indias-manipur-state-grip-ethnic-violence-2023-07-21/


    Consequently Kukis and Nagas started an agitation, which led to violence, including burning of churches, rape of women, two Kuki women paraded naked, and killing of 142 people.


    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2023_Manipur_violence


    https://www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-india-66260730


    https://www.indiatodayne.in/manipur/story/manipur-violence-7-kuki-zomi-women-raped-8-bludgeoned-to-death-5-shot-dead-claims-vaipei-peoples-council-619416-2023-07-23


    https://www.ndtv.com/india-news/manipur-women-paraded-naked-video-manipur-violence-1-more-arrested-amid-massive-manhunt-over-horrific-manipur-video-case-4231123


    https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2023/7/10/no-end-to-deadly-violence-in-indias-ethnically-divided-manipur


    Kukis were forcibly evicted from their homes in some villages


    https://www.thequint.com/opinion/manipur-violence-unease-over-land-st-status-worsening-meitei-kuki-mistrust


    10 tribal MLAs, including a BJP tribal MLA, have alleged state complicity in the violence


    https://www.ndtv.com/india-news/manipur-women-video-manipur-violence-latest-proof-of-state-complicity-manipur-bjp-mla-paolienlal-haokip-claims-ethnic-violence-was-avoidable-4234147

    In my opinion 3 steps must immediately be taken to remedy the situation :

    (1). The Manipur govt must be dismissed, and the state be placed under Central rule, as it is a clear case where Article 356 of the Constitution should be invoked.

    Article 356 states :

    ” If the President, on receipt of report from the Governor of the State or otherwise, is satisfied that a situation has arisen in which the government of the State cannot be carried on in accordance with he provisions of this Constitution, the President may be Proclamation

    (a) assume to himself all or any of the functions of the Government of the State and all or any of the powers vested in or exercisable by the Governor or any body or authority in the State other than the Legislature of the State;

    (b) declare that the powers of the Legislature of the State shall be exercisable by or under the authority of Parliament ”

    It is obvious that the government of Manipur is unable to carry on functioning in accordance with the provisions of the Constitution since it has taken a partisan approach to side with the Meiteis, and against the Kukis and Nagas, and is unable to control the ethnic violence.

    (2) Police officers who sided with Meiteis or turned a Nelson’s eye to the violence must immediately be suspended and charge sheeted

    (3) A petition should immediately be filed before the National Human Rights Commission, Delhi

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XNFbo_e5pZs&pp=ygUjd2hhdCBpcyBoYXBwZW5pbmcgaW4gbWFuaXB1ciBwYXJ0IDI%3D


    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Kj3kR_XtvKU&pp=ygUjd2hhdCBpcyBoYXBwZW5pbmcgaW4gbWFuaXB1ciBwYXJ0IDI%3D

  • How to make India free

    How to make India free


    By Justice Katju
    Now that the name of Mughal Gardens In Rashtrapati Bhawan has been changed to Amrit Udyan, chapters on Mughal history have been ordered to be removed from the history syllabus by NCERT, the name of my hometown Allahabad changed to Prayagraj, Fyzabad changed to Ayodhya, Mughalsarai Junction changed to Pt Deen Dayal Upadhyaya Junction, Aurangabad changed to Sambhajinagar etc, and Babri Masjid demolished to give way to construction of a ‘bhavya’ Ram Mandir, I suggest the following steps be also taken to make India really free from all traces of of our detested oppressors, invaders and enslavers :


    https://www.dw.com/en/why-is-india-hinduizing-cities-muslim-names/a-46259523

    1. Demolish Red Fort, Qutub Minar, Humayun’s tomb and Jama Masjid In Delhi
    2. Demolish Taj Mahal In Agra
    3. Close down Aligarh Muslim University In Aligarh, Jamia Milia in Delhi, Osmania University In Hyderabad, and Dar-ul- Uloom in Deoband
    4. Demolish Char Minar In Hyderabad and other Muslim constructions In India
    5. Close down Ajmer dargah and Nizamuddin Aulia dargah
    6. Close down Urdu, Persian and Arabic Departments In all Universities and Colleges In India
      7 Ban singing of songs in which Urdu or Persian words are used ( Hindi film songs use a lot of Urdu, and so they particularly should be banned ). Ban songs by Mohammed Rafi, Talat Mehmood, Ghulam Ali, Mehdi Hasan, Begum Akhtar and other Muslim singers
    7. Ban recitation of Urdu shaayari, and for this ban mushairas
    8. Ban teaching of Hindi poetry by Muslim poets like Rahim, Raskhan, Jaayasi, etc in our educational institutions
    9. Change Muslim names of all cities, mohallas, villages and other places in India and give them Hindu names
      And finally, accelerate the ‘ghar waapasi’ programme
      This should be done before the 2024 Lok Sabha elections

    Hari Om

  • Justice Katju: Criminal neglect by Kerala Govt

    Justice Katju: Criminal neglect by Kerala Govt



    While Kerala has done extremely well in primary education and has practically wiped out illiteracy ( it is perhaps the best state in India in this regard ), education after class 10 has been criminally neglected.


    This I found personally during my recent visit there. Bright students who had secured over 90% marks in their class 10 Board exams, could not get admission seats in class 11 to pursue engineering, computers, medicine, etc. so that they could become engineers, doctors, computer specialists, scientists, etc


    The current government does not seem to bother that they are playing with the lives of the youth


    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iJupmbVwvSE&pp=ygUNanVzdGljZSBrYXRqdQ%3D%3D


    I appeal to Keralites to start large scale public demonstrations and protests against this govt, particularly against the CM and Ministers, who should be socially boycotted, unless they rectify this terrible situation
    Justice Katju
    Former Judge, Supreme Court of India
    23.7.2023

  • Yeh Hindustan ke Sultanate ki ladai hai: Justice Katju

    Yeh Hindustan ke Sultanate ki ladai hai: Justice Katju


    There is a lot of speculation about the 2024 Indian Lok Sabha elections, particularly after 26 Opposition parties came together in Bangalore ( 17 parties had earlier met in Patna ), and they are scheduled to meet again in Mumbai


    https://indianexpress.com/article/political-pulse/meet-the-26-where-the-opposition-parties-meeting-in-bengaluru-stand-8846893/


    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bCbAvb0kCGY


    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eod3do8ZmYE


    They have decided to call their united front India, and will set up a coordination committee and a secretariat


    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=W-eJpQL7LLM


    https://www.livemint.com/politics/news/upa-gets-new-name-next-opposition-meeting-to-be-held-in-mumbai-highlights-from-26-party-meet-in-bengaluru-11689677932935.html


    In my opinion this endeavour will not be able to stop BJP from coming to power again in 2024. Let me give my reasons.


    To understand indian politics one must know that Indian society is still largely semi-feudal, as is evident from the rampant casteism and communalism prevalent here. This is why Indian politics runs largely on the basis of caste and religious vote banks.


    Before the BJP came to power in the centre in 2014 most ‘secular’parties like the Congress, Samajwadi Party ( in UP ), Rashtriya Janta Dal ( in Bihar ), etc which were at one time in power, relied on some caste vote bank plus the Muslim vote bank ( which is fairly large in North india ).


    On the other hand, the BJP knows it will not get Muslim votes. So their best tactic is to unite the 80% Hindu population of India, claiming to be their representative.
    Now Hindu upper castes ( i.e. Brahmins, Rajputs, Banias, Bhumihars, etc ) , who are altogether about 18-20% in UP, Bihar, etc are, and will remain, solidly with the BJP.
    But to win elections 18-20% votes is not enough. One needs another chunk of about 15% votes. How does one get that ? That is the big problem for the BJP.


    In UP they solved the problem earlier by winning over a sizeable chunk of the OBC votes. In UP, OBCs ( which comprise of several castes e,.g. Yadavs, Kurmis, Lodhs, etc ) are about 40% of the total population. Of these, the largest caste is Yadavs, who are about 9 or 10%. The feeling among many non Yadav OBCs was that Samajwadi Party cares only for Yadavs, and gives them plum postings of DM, SP, daroga, etc when coming to power in UP, while ignoring non Yadav OBCs.


    This grievance was capitalised by the BJP, which managed to win over many non Yadav OBCs like Kurmis, Kushwahas etc ( a Kushwaha is Dy CM in UP ) They also won over a section of the Scheduled Castes ( though the majority remained with Mayawati’s BSP ).


    However, whereas the upper caste Hindus will remain with the BJP, come what may, that cannot be said about the section of OBCs and SCs who earlier voted for the BJP. They are at best unreliable partners, and may shift their votes.
    To ensure that this done not happen, and these OBCs and SCs remain securely in the BJP camp, some well organised communal riots and communal incidents a few months before the elections, to consolidate the 80% Hindus, will surely be engineered, and will do the trick. In a communally surcharged atmosphere Hindus of all castes tend to unite as against the Muslims, as it happened during the Ram Mandir agitation.
    Another possible tactic may be to have a short war with Pakistan, or a ‘surgical strike’. This too may surcharge the emotions of Hindus, to make them vote en bloc for the BJP.


    One thing can be said for sure. The BJP will not easily give up power, and for this use all saam, daam, dand, bhed possible.
    Yeh Hindustan ki sultanate ki ladai hai. Rivers of blood have flown over centuries in the fights to capture the Delhi throne. Something similar can be expected in 2024
    .

  • Justice Katju: Protocol facilities to judges

    Justice Katju: Protocol facilities to judges


    By Justice Katju
    I entirely agree with the Chief Justice of India who said recently that judges should not treat protocol facilities as manifestations of power


    https://www.hindustantimes.com/india-news/chief-justice-of-india-calls-for-self-reflection-and-counselling-after-judge-demands-explanation-from-railway-officials-101689879336251.html


    https://www.freepressjournal.in/mumbai/mumbai-news-cji-dy-chandrachud-displeased-with-letter-by-disgruntled-allahabad-hc-judge-to-railways


    https://thewire.in/law/judge-explanation-railways-cji-chandrachud-displeasure


    It appears that an Allahabad High Court Judge was upset over what he regarded as ill treatment by the railway personnel during his train journey from New Delhi to Allahabad. At his instance the Registrar General of the High Court wrote a letter to the railway authorities making basically two complaints :
    (1) There were no GRP ( General Railway Police ) personnel to meet his requirements.
    (2) Pantry car workers did not attend to the judge’s requirements to provide refreshments.
    Now I have travelled several times by train while a judge, but never expected GRP personnel or pantry car workers to attend on me. Why should the police attend on me ? And as for food and water, I would always bring it with me for the journey.


    When I became Acting Chief Justice of the Allahabad High Court ( in August 2004 ) I saw a policeman on a motor cycle in front of my car, and a jeep full of armed policemen following my car, when travelling from my home to the High Court. I asked my secretary ( who was in my car ) ” Who are these jokers ? ”. He replied that they were my escort. I said I dont need any, tell them to buzz off.


    My secretary said that under the relevant rules, the Chief Justice must have an escort, so I had no choice in the matter.


    After I became Chief Justice of Madras High Court ( in November 2004 ), I travelled by train from Chennai to Madurai ( where a new bench of the High Court had been created ). A huge number of policemen along with other officials were at Madurai railway station to receive me. From the station to the High Court building is about 10 kms distance, and at every 100 or 200 yards on the route there were policemen standing in the sun to salute me.


    In the evening I called the IGP, Southern Range, and told him that police are meant primarily to protect the public. By deploying half or more of the police force in Madurai to salute me he had left the public unprotected, so that thieves and other criminals could have a field day. I told him I have no ego problem, and requested him not to do this in future.


    After I became Chief Justice of Delhi High Court ( in October 2005 ) some of my colleagues in the High Court complained that they were frisked at the airport during security check, and this was an insult. I said everybody is frisked at the airport at security, and judges are not a privileged class above the law.


    As the Chief Justice I too always spread my hands at the security check at the airport, and found no loss of dignity in being frisked
    Judges must have modesty and humility, and not behave like Emperors